Posted by
BGH
~
For your entertainment I thought I would share a recent discussion I have been enjoying on Reddit. It seems someone submitted the news story regarding the Pope's comments in reference to science last week. I saw this poster's remark, and just had to respond, I wanted to know why just serving up the news story was anti-religious discrimination. Obviously the believer's favorite argument against one who is skeptical is the strawman fallacy and it is well employed by this user.
Meet:
- Riman34
- Downvoted for anti-religious discrimination.
BGHAwww, will your imaginary friend be offended?
- Riman34
- Ooo! Are you taking pleasure from torturing little children, you monster?
BGHTorturing children?
As the Catholic Priests do by buttfucking and molesting every little boy they can get their hands on?
No, actually I have no magic invisible friend to tell me that sex between two consenting adults is bad, so I enjoy that instead.
How about you?
- Riman34
- Ooo! It's well known that every pedophile and rapist need a catholic priesthood diploma...Can I call you "moron", please?
- Me? I'm quite well. I don't have AIDS. Neither flesh-eating MRSA bacteria.
BGHOh, your right, it's not a requirement. Once you do get that degree though, you have a pretty good start.
Why call it torturing little children to let them know this 'god' figure is no different than Santa Clause and is a man made concept? Wouldn't it be torture the other way around? Tell them this thing exists only to find out later it was a big lie and very much wishful thinking?
- Riman34
- A good Start? Oh really! I didn't know that Theological courses were about learning CIA torture techniques.
- Go on, explain your non-sense.
BGHHa ha ha ha ha ha!
Since when is pedophilia a CIA torture technique?
How about answering the question of why you call it torture?
I'll ask it again, why call it torturing little children to let them know this 'god' figure is no different than Santa Clause and is a man made concept? Wouldn't it be torture the other way around? Tell them this thing exists only to find out later it was a big lie and very much wishful thinking?
- Riman34
- Fantasies are common things for children. They love stories, you didn't know?
- So delude yourserlf with your pathetic pseudo-rationality unable to explain basic youth psychology.
BGHYou do realize, that I understand enough about psychology to ascertain, you are off your rocker.
By the way, nice dodge again on the question.
- Riman34
- If you understand youth psychology , and if you understand that children loves stories, love Santa Claus, why do you want to make them cry ? I don't think you realize how fragile are children minds.
BGHSeriously, you haven't slightest clue!
Why not tell them fantasy and make believe is great. But it is just that, fantasy and make believe, they need to know that so they do not confuse fantasy with reality.
How long would you have them believe in Santa? 10yrs? 20yrs? If you purport something like that to be true and they find out it isn't they will cry, no matter the age. If they know it isn't real from the start and it is just make-believe they will be much better off to deal with reality.
Additionally, if telling them god doesn't exist is similar to telling them santa isn't real, are you admitting this 'god' thing is just santa for grown-ups?

- Riman34
- I don't think you understand at all youth psychology. Children love stories, because they need it ! They can't rationalize complex things. And when they grow up, they realize by themselves.
- "God" is a pratical name for spirituality. And spirituality is about things that mankind is unable to understand : Infinity, Eternity, etc...
BGHFunny, I have a child, he rationalizes very well. I don't think you understand youth psychology, purporting a lie to them only makes them distrustful when they learn the truth. He understands that anything he wants to ask I will give him an honest answer instead of making up a fairy tale.
Your so-called 'spirituality' is hogwash also, because we can't understand something doesn't mean we make up a name and answer. We say we don't understand yet, and as long as we keep an open mind, we may eventually find out. We do not fabricate an answer that 'feels good' and stop there, nothing is ever learned that way.
Try again.
- Riman34
- Oh, great! And now you are deniying the very existence of religions and spiritualities.
- Troll !
- By the way, mankind is unable to understand infinity. It's a mind limit fact.
BGHHave you seen a psychiatrist lately? You seem to be exhibiting classic 'projection' by calling me a troll.
I think I have been rather reasonable in this discussion, you on the other hand have straw manned nearly every point I have given and made very broad assumptions you can't back up.
I won't resort to calling you a 'troll', rather you have weak argumentation and are not substantiating anything you say. I think I shall call you, 'nutjob' or 'moron'.
I hope we can have more encounters in other posts because you done such an excellent job of illustrating how to employ logical fallacies and distorted reasoning.
Have a nice evening, moron.
---------------------------------
I tried not to be too rough on the poster until the end, but restraint was very difficult.
----